Understanding Access to Care for Rural Residents With Disabilities
Date:
Duration: approximately
minutes
From This Webinar
Rural residents have higher rates of disability and face unique barriers to accessing high-quality care. In this webinar, researchers from the University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center shared results from a project examining access to care at the intersection of rurality and disability. These results included county-level analyses comparing disability rates, workforce shortages, and quality of care. They also shared results from the National Health Interview Survey examining differences in barriers to care and use of preventive services by rural-urban location and disability status. Additionally, two case studies of programs in Minnesota and Idaho that support the transportation needs of rural residents with disabilities were discussed.
Additional Resource of Interest
Featured Speakers
|
Carrie Henning-Smith, PhD, MPH,
MSW Professor, Division of Health Policy & Management Co-Director, University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center |
|
Katie Rydberg, MPH Research Scientist, University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center |
|
Mariana Tuttle, MPH Research Scientist, University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center |
Transcript
Per Ostmo: Thank you for joining us. My name is Per Ostmo. I'm the program director for the Rural Health Research Gateway. I'll drop my email into the chat, so please reach out if you have any questions. If you are unfamiliar with Gateway, we provide easy and timely access to research conducted by the Federal Office of Rural Health Policy funded Rural Health Research Centers. You can stay up to date on the latest rural health research by subscribing to Gateway's research emails or by following Gateway on social media. During today's webinar, the research team from the University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center will share results from a project examining access to care at the intersection of rurality and disability. Please note that all attendees have been muted, but you may submit questions for our speakers using the Q&A function. We will handle Q&A at the end.
Today's session will be recorded and posted to the Gateway website for later viewing. Our presenters today are Dr. Carrie Henning-Smith. She is a co-director of the University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center. We also have Katie Rydberg, a research scientist with the center, and Mariana Tuttle, also a research scientist with the center. So now I'm going to hand things off to our first presenter, which is Dr. Carrie Henning-Smith.
Carrie Henning-Smith: Thank you, Per. And thank you everyone for spending this hour with us digging into what I think is a critically important topic in both rural health and in the health and well-being of people with disabilities. We are going to be covering a lot of ground today, and we're excited to share the results of a year-long project that was conducted, as Per said, with funding from the Federal Office of Rural Health Policy. We will be going through all of the work that we did in this project, and if you're interested in more detailed results or looking at any of the things that we've written, they are all available. Per is going to offer some links to those at the end of the webinar, and we are excited to be able to share those with you.
I want to acknowledge the team that stands behind this work. I am presenting alongside my colleagues, Mariana and Katie today, but we couldn't have done this work without our broader team who we collaborated with on all pieces of this. You can see the team listed there. And also, of course, thanks again to the Federal Office of Rural Health Policy for funding this work. I'm going to start by grounding us in some background and in some statements that we know to be true. I'm going to read these out and then I'm going to walk more slowly through each piece of this so that we can tie it together and understand the motivation for this work. First, rural residents have poorer health outcomes than urban residents. People with disabilities have poorer health outcomes than people without disabilities. Rural residents experience barriers to accessing care, and people with disabilities experience barriers to accessing care.
Finally, rural residents have higher rates of disability than urban residents. We knew all of these things to be true before we set out on this project, and you will see the ways that we tried to address all of the ways that these come together in the work that we did. But first, in case you're not convinced, and I suspect that you probably are if you're listening to this webinar, so maybe I'm preaching to the choir here, but I'm going to go through some background on each of those statements that I just gave to offer the motivation for this work. First, rural health outcomes. We could obviously spend hours and hours just talking about this. Instead, I'm going to offer one slide that tries to sum together some of what we know about rural health disparities and rural health outcomes. You may have heard of a concept called the rural mortality penalty.
This is a concept that has been coined by scholars and emerged in the early 1980s. Prior to that, mortality rates were relatively high for all groups and declining. They were getting better as medical care, clinical care got better, and especially as public health measures and addressing structural determinants got better. However, in the early 1980s, health outcomes between rural and urban residents started to diverge, get wider, and we have seen them increasingly widen in recent years. Rural residents die sooner and more frequently than urban residents. We could also talk about any number of health outcomes, chronic conditions, and we would see similar rural and urban patterns. Now turning to disability, we see similar things by disability. And here I'm speaking about disability broadly, and I want to acknowledge that disability is a broad and vast concept encompassing physical disability, encompassing developmental cognitive disability. There's a lot wrapped up in here and we're not going to be able to parse apart each different type of disability. So I just want to acknowledge that from the outset as a caveat here.
But looking overall at disability, this comes from a systematic review, understanding the mortality risk of disability compared with people who don't have disability. You can see here the relative risk ratio, that is how much more likely is someone with disability to experience mortality compared with someone without disability. And you can see that for all adults with disability, the relative risk ratio is higher, almost twice the rate of people without disability, and that remains consistent across age groups.
So now turning to access to care. Again, I suspect that I'm preaching to the choir and that many of you are here because you already think about or work in rural health, and so I probably don't need to convince you that there are specific issues related to accessing care in rural places. But that said, I think it's useful to just ground us all in the same foundation so that we have the same background knowledge here. There are many ways to look at access to care. Again, we could spend hours just digging into this topic. We're not going to do that, I promise. I'm just going to share a few examples of ways that rural residents experience systematically different access to care than their urban counterparts.
First, and perhaps most widely known are hospital closures. Rural hospitals are more likely than urban hospitals to close, and we have seen approximately 200 rural hospitals close in the past two decades. This slide here is from our colleagues at the University of North Carolina showing where those rural hospital closures have occurred. In the yellow, those are the hospital closures that have occurred since 2010, and the blue are those that occurred between 2005 and 2010. But it's not just hospital closures. We've seen a decline in pharmacy availability in rural places. This here shows the change in the number of brick and mortar retail pharmacies by geography. Rural non-core counties are in red and rural micropolitan counties are in green. And you can see here that over the past 20, 25 years, both types of rural counties have experienced a decline in pharmacy availability.
We can also talk about nursing homes. This chart from our colleagues at the RUPRI Center for Rural Health Policy Analysis shows where there are counties without any nursing home or skilled nursing facility. Those in the mustardy brown color are rural non-metropolitan counties. Those in the teal are metropolitan counties. You can see that rural counties are much more likely to not have a nursing home, and we have seen similar declines in the availability of nursing homes in recent years and recent decades disproportionately impacting rural people and places. Obviously, a need for skilled nursing facility is intricately tied with disability, especially in older ages and in places where nursing homes are not available. It makes it more challenging for individuals to receive the long-term services and supports they might need.
Looking at the other end of the lifespan here at the University of Minnesota Rural Health Research Center, our colleagues have done a lot of work looking at loss of obstetric services in recent decades. This chart shows the percentage of US rural and urban counties where there is a hospital with obstetric services available. You can see that in both rural and urban counties, there's been a decline in recent decades, but that decline has been more severe and more dramatic in rural places. Today, fewer than 40% of rural counties have a hospital with obstetric services available.
And then one other important dimension of access to care is the workforce. There's a lot to say about workforce in rural places. I'm just going to share one example here looking at physicians per 10,000 people. In the light blue are metro or urban counties, and in the dark blue are non-metro or rural counties. You can see that rural counties have vastly fewer physicians per capita than urban counties. We could go through any number of other provider types and you would see a similar story. And again, we're going to come back to this in our results, but thinking about people who need specialty care, who have complex conditions, perhaps paired with disability, having workforce shortages makes it that much harder to have those specific needs met.
So getting to our next point, access to care for people with disabilities, we see a similar story to what I showed you with rural access to care where people with disability have specific challenges in accessing the care that they need. This is a chart from the Centers for Disease Control showing that one in four or a quarter of adults with disabilities ages 18 to 44 don't have a usual healthcare provider. One in five had an unmet healthcare need because of cost in the past year, and one in four did not have a routine checkup in the past year. These are concerning numbers for any populations. And when we think about people with disabilities and some of the specific and complex situations that they may have, this becomes even more concerning.
This is from a systematic review looking at research, understanding access to care for people with disabilities that was published earlier this year and showing why people with disability may experience some of those challenges accessing care. We're going to come back to some of these themes later in the research that we show, but I just want to show that the most common barrier by far is an economic barrier, financial constraints, cost, insurance and poverty. This is really important as we think about changes to federal and state insurance policy, access to insurance, but we also see that other barriers become really important too, things like accessibility around transportation and physical access to care, healthcare system barriers, provider training, organizations, staffing, communication and information, awareness, communication about services. And then falling toward the bottom, but still important are social and attitudinal barriers and individual and patient level barriers to care.
So finally, wrapping up our background and moving toward our results, rural individuals have higher rates of disability than urban individuals. This slide is also from the CDC and has data that's getting old at this point and yet remains fairly consistent with what we see in the numbers today. This shows the gradient of rurality from most rural, those non-core rural counties to most urban, those large central metropolitan counties. And you can see that disability rates increase as rurality increases. This is using disability measures from the BRFSS, the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System, and it shows that more than a third of rural non-core counties have a disability as measured by the BRFSS.
Finally, ending our background piece, I just want to make the point that disability rates and rurality are not monolithic across the United States. They vary widely and we see a variation that matters for policy, that matters for how we address some of the issues that we'll be talking about today. This chart shows the share of the US population with a disability. This is using a different measure of disability. This is the disability measure from the American Community Survey, which asks whether people have serious limitations in any of six different domains. And you can see that disability rates using this measure are highest in the South, in Appalachia, that they tend to be a little bit lower in the upper Midwest, but that across all states, more than 10% of people with the rare exception of Utah have a disability and we need to be thinking about their needs in addressing health issues.
So bringing this all together, we knew these issues in setting out to do this project, but what we didn't know was what was happening at the intersection of rurality and disability. There was surprisingly little literature trying to understand the health access issues, the health outcomes of people at that intersection of rural residents with disability. To address that gap, we sought to answer three main research questions. First, how do county level rates of disability intersect with rurality and access to or quality of care? Second, are there rural and urban differences in the use of and barriers to care? And then finally, what are some promising models for improving access to care for rural residents with disabilities? I will walk us through the first question and then I will pass it off to my colleague Mariana to walk us through the second question, and then my colleague Katie Rydberg will walk us through some case studies at the end of promising models.
So at the county level, in this analysis, we use the American Community Survey to look at percent of disability across counties. The American Community Survey is administered by the US Census Bureau and interviews 2.5% to 3% of households annually. The American Community Survey Measure of Disability asked people whether they have serious difficulty in hearing, vision, cognitive functioning, ambulatory functioning, self-care and independent living. This is a fairly broad measure and it's widely used to understand disability rates across the US population.
We first sought to see whether there were differences between county level disability rates and rates of health professional shortage areas. In short, we wanted to understand whether those counties with the highest rates of disability also had the greatest workforce shortages and whether that differed by virality. We did this work looking separately at individuals 19 to 64 and 65 plus. And I'm going to show you a few of the results here. Again, all of these results are available in publicly available policy briefs on our website or through the Gateway if you'd like to see these in more detail because we're going to be flying through them today. But first, what we found is that for primary care HPSAs, health professional shortage areas, the rate of county being a HPSA increased as the rate of disability increased. First quartile are the lowest rates of disability by county and fourth quartile are the highest rates.
There was also a rural urban differential across all counties, but that differential shrunk as disability rates increased. What this tells us is that rural counties with the highest rates of disability are the most likely to be HPSAs. Urban counties with the highest rates of disability are second most likely to be HPSAs. This tells us that counties with the greatest need perhaps are the least well-served. We saw the same story for dental care HPSAs as the level of disability at the county increased, so did the likelihood of that county being a HPSA and those increases were more dramatic in rural places. And finally, the same story for mental healthcare HPSAs, although it's worth noting that most rural counties have mental healthcare, health professional shortage areas are designated as mental health care HPSAs. And so we didn't see as much variation by disability rate and yet we still saw some.
And then the second and final piece of county level work I'm going to walk us through is looking at county level disability rates and how they intersect with Medicare quality. For this, we combined those ACS disability prevalence at the county level with three measures of fee-for-service Medicare quality, whether individuals had received a flu vaccination, whether individuals who qualified received a mammography in the past year, and then rates of ambulatory-sensitive hospitalization. All of those measures were taken from the county health rankings. Here, what we found is that the higher the county level disability prevalence, again, from first quartile is lowest to fourth quartile is highest, the prevalence of flu vaccination decreased. So the higher the county level disability prevalence, the lower the flu vaccination rate that tells us in the places with the highest disability, they're least likely to be receiving a flu vaccination. And that was especially true for rural counties.
We saw the same story for mammography screening. So the higher the disability prevalence, the lower the mammography screening, especially true for rural counties. In those rural counties with the highest disability prevalence, just over a third of individuals who qualified received a mammography or a mammogram in the past year.
And finally, we saw the same story for rates of ambulatory care sensitive hospitalizations where those increased as disability prevalence increased, and that was especially true for rural counties. Altogether, these county-based findings tell us that the counties with the greatest need as measured by disability prevalence are the least well-served by healthcare providers and they have the poorest quality outcomes. So certainly opportunity for improvement here. Now I'm going to pass it off to my colleague Mariana to walk us through the next set of findings.
Mariana Tuttle: Thanks, Carrie. You can go ahead and pop to the next slide please. So before we move on to the National Health Interview Survey, which is our next measure or next instrument I should say that we used for quantitative analysis on this project, before I jump into the specific questions that we asked and the resulting publications, I just want to share a little bit about the NHIS. It is an annually nationally representative survey of the civilian US population that's a non-institutionalized civilian population, which is why you see the GIF here. You get a survey, everybody gets a survey. It's not really true, but it is a nationally representative survey that's designed to mirror the US population overall. So for those not in active military or residential facilities like nursing homes or psychiatric facilities, it's also the longest running continuous health survey and it's conducted by the US Census Bureau on behalf of the National Center for Health Statistics.
And the primary objective of the NHIS is to monitor the health of the US population through data collected on a whole broad range of topics like medical conditions or health insurance, doctor's visits, other health behaviors. But for our purposes, we used this survey and we were wanting to examine a couple of different measures around access to care and barriers of access to care by rurality and disability status as well as quality of care. We used data from 2022 from the NHIS because that year included additional questions on access to care, and we were largely conducting this work back in 2024, so it was the most comprehensive year of survey data available at that point. And we included all adults ages 18 and older with complete information on our measures of interest. So let's dive into our first question and the first publication that we did.
We first wanted to understand barriers to accessing care and how they vary by rurality and by disability status. And our motivation behind this question comes from the fact that it is abundantly clear that access to healthcare is important, though not sufficient for supporting good health outcomes. And as Carrie just walked through, we knew things about rural folks with access to care. We knew things about folks with disabilities and their access to care, but we wanted to examine this at the intersection here of rurality and disability and how did this [inaudible 00:23:23]? But let me pause just really quickly and define access. We see that as an individual's ability to obtain and to use needed healthcare services without unnecessary barriers. So in health services and population health research, we often refer to the five A's of access. Those are availability, provider or facility availability, affordability, accessibility relates to distance and transportation, travel time, accommodation, so what their office hours are, appointment wait times, and acceptability, which refers to kind of a cultural alignment or comfort alignment between the patient and the provider or facility.
So just challenges and just mostly wanted to point that out because I think we can think of the challenges in any one of these areas as presenting barriers to getting care. And challenges in access to care are important to understand as a component of addressing differences in health outcomes. Carrie already mentioned all of the challenges that we know exist, and so examining this intersection of rurality and disability felt like a really critical part of the equation. Next slide please.
We examined differences in access to healthcare. Well, I should say we examined access to healthcare through several individual variables that we grouped as non-financial and financial barriers to care. Non-financial access barriers were those reporting yes to a delay in care or not getting medical care due to specific barriers that we'll look at more in depth in the next couple of slides, and respondents could select any number of barriers that applied. Rural residency was defined using the 2013 NCHS Rural Urban Classification Scheme with all non-metro counties being referred to as rural.
And I assessed disability through a pretty standard composite measure where respondents were defined as having a disability if they report having, quote, "a lot of difficulty" or quote, "cannot do at all" certain measures, which I won't go into in detail. Again, all of these are fully available on our website or through the Rural Health Research Gateway, but those kinds of measures included things like difficulty remembering or concentrating, walking or climbing stairs, hearing or vision. Just a note that a limitation of that measure is that it probably underestimates the size of the population with disabilities as it focuses just on those two highest severity categories instead of having any difficulty with any of the measures. And for this policy brief... So go ahead. You got it. You got it, Carrie.
So our results, all I was going to say is that we used chi-square test to determine what was statistically significantly different here, which is a little bit different than our more in-depth predictive probability analysis that we'll go into in the next paper, but for this one here. So what did we find? Here you can see the seven non-financial access to care barriers by rurality and disability status. The rural residents here are in gold, urban are in maroon. Folks with disabilities are also darker, so that brighter gold and the darker maroon than folks without disabilities. And you can see here that for the majority of individual access to barriers that we examined, we were more likely to find differences between people with and without disabilities rather than between rural and urban residents.
So the most commonly reported non-financial barriers overall were delaying care due to appointment availability. That's the third one there from the left. Having a busy schedule that is specific to non-disabled respondents and due to lack of transportation, that was especially an issue for rural residents with disabilities. We found that over 11% of rural people with disabilities and over 15% of urban people with disabilities delayed care due to appointment availability, and almost 16% of rural people with disabilities and 14% of urban folks with disabilities delayed care due to lack of transportation.
And moving on here to our financial barriers and access to care, figure two here is showing those four financial access barriers by rurality and disability status. And for the sake of time and knowing what the remaining slides are, I just want to emphasize here that folks with disabilities were significantly more likely to report all four financial barriers regardless of whether they lived in a rural or urban area than folks without disabilities. Again, the story here seeming to be much more about challenges for folks with disabilities compared to their non-disabled peers rather than a major rural urban disparity for this group. In terms of the implications we see from this and the prior slide's results, we know that many individuals with disabilities have limited incomes that likely impacts each of these access barriers and requires additions to employment and income benefit policies to ensure they're adequate to meet individuals' basic needs.
It would be helpful for policies to reflect also accessibility needs for people with disabilities tailored to location specific needs. You'll recall on the prior slide, we saw that a lack of transportation and travel time were more common among those with disabilities regardless of location, highlighting just a need for accessible clinics close to where people with disabilities live and with expanded public or medical transportation options available. I think that's especially critical in rural areas. And financial access differences between those with and without disabilities were particularly evident here in delaying dental care and prescriptions you can see here due to cost. Those are the most stark measures and I think the most stark differences, which highlights the possibility of more expansive insurance coverage, especially to include and reduce out-of-pocket spending for dental and prescription costs. I know, for example, Medicare does not cover routine dental care, and while state Medicaid programs are required to provide dental care for folks up to age 21, services for adults are optional and really vary by state Medicaid program.
And delaying or forgoing dental care could impact overall health and well-being. Dental visits can serve as preventative care as well as screen for other disease or health concerns that manifest orally. For example, periodontal disease has been linked to things like heart disease or diabetes. And certain pregnancy outcomes as well. And finally on this one, our findings highlight appointment availability and lack of facility operating hours as more commonly being reported by individuals with disabilities. That highlights a need for expanded facility capacity, including longer hours and increasing operating hours to evenings through weekends might reduce challenges for people with disabilities and their potential caregivers who might be unable to take time off of other responsibilities during the day.
So next, we zoomed in to access barriers for only rural residents by disability status. We authored this brief report, which we published in the Journal of Rural Health. Here we limited our analysis to rural adults 18 and older with complete information on our sample sociodemographics. For this product, I'll just say our sample size is much, much smaller than our prior policy brief and then the policy brief that we're going to examine next. And we used the same measures of rurality and disability status. And we saw value in this closer look at just rural residents, especially as it allowed us to do some more complex analyses than just the bivariates that we showed for the policy brief. So that attempts to get at a likelihood of an outcome given a set of conditions rather than just examine the correlation between two variables.
And looking among rural residents, we were able to compare all 11 separate access barriers by disability status and we generated adjusted predicted probabilities of experiencing these barriers controlling for sociodemographic characteristics. So we found that compared to those without disabilities, rural people, again, we're just looking among rural residents. So rural people with disabilities had significantly higher adjusted predicted probabilities of 8 of the 11 access barriers. That included all 4 of those financial barriers, delaying medical care, dental care, and mental health care due to cost and not being able to afford those prescriptions. And then on the non-financial side, that included delaying care due to facility hours, insurance acceptance, transportation, and travel time. And delaying care we know can exacerbate health outcomes. So these findings have negative implications for rural population health generally, which are even more exacerbated, I would say, for rural people with disabilities.
But despite facing greater barriers to accessing healthcare overall, one thing that we did find for rural residents with disabilities is that they were more likely to report having a usual source of care than their rural counterparts without disabilities. And we believe this finding reflects a greater need for ongoing medical management among many people with disabilities and they may be more likely to establish continuous care relationships. In turn, having an ongoing relationship with a provider may help that provider to tailor treatment recommendations to best meet individuals' needs and personal circumstances to reduce barriers to care.
The results of this paper have similar implications for public policy as to what I just presented in our policy brief where we examined a role for insurance and employment programs to meeting those financial needs, especially insurance generosity and some logistical access concerns related to transportation and travel time. We highlighted the potential role of the need for more accessible clinics and medical facilities close to where people with disabilities live. And also I wanted to mention potential for expanded Americans disabilities without accessible public or medical transportation options in rural areas especially.
So next slide here. Taking what we know and what we've just learned about access to care at the intersection of rurality and disability, our final quantitative analysis using the NHIS explored dimensions of quality of care for these populations. So quality can sometimes be difficult to measure, but one category that researchers often use to look at quality is preventive services with the rationale that appropriate use of preventive services keeps populations healthy, identifies risks early and acts on evidence-based guidelines. So high quality healthcare, including the use of preventive services, is important to maximize health and wellbeing. And we know that rural residents and people with disabilities separately experience specific health barriers to quality care, but less is known about the preventive care use at the intersection of disability status and rurality, and even less is known about how those relationships vary by insurance status. So that is what we decided to explore in this policy brief and we'll have four different tables that we'll walk through starting with table one on the next slide.
Great. So with the measures we use for disability and for rurality here are the same too as the other publications I just shared, so I won't go into detail there. But again, because we, like we did for the first policy brief, looked at all individuals with complete measures, not just rural residents, we're going back here to that larger sample size with an N of over 27,000. And we examined the use of preventive services through two specific individual variables, whether respondents had indicated that they had a wellness or general purpose physical checkup in the last year and receipt of the flu vaccine in the last year. Health insurance status was categorized as private, dual eligible, Medicare Advantage, original Medicare, Medicaid, and other government insurance, which included state, military, and federal insurance and uninsured. That is what you can see here in table one, the distribution of health insurance type within each rurality and disability subgroup.
Let's see. You know what? I will go through this. So we can see here briefly that about 64% of urban people with disabilities and almost 58% of rural people without disabilities had private insurance. So folks without disabilities more likely to have private insurance. About 26% of rural people with disabilities and 21% of urban people with disabilities had Medicaid for insurance. And rural people without disabilities were the most likely to be uninsured. We'll have quite a bit of, I want you all to look at and think about that uninsured population because that comes up quite a bit in the results in the next few slides.
Let's see. Next slide please. Okay, so here table two shows the associations between rurality, disability status and health insurance type across each of these two preventative measures that I just mentioned. I won't spend too much time on this descriptive table because our next two tables look at predicted probabilities of our measures of interest, that's the physical and the flu vaccine. So here this is just kind of a whole swath of information around rurality, disability, age, and insurance status.
And a couple of highlights I'll just say before we move on is that a larger percentage of urban residents compared to rural residents overall had received a flu vaccine. And that people with disabilities were more likely overall to have had a routine physical and more likely to be vaccinated for the flu in the last year compared to people without disabilities. And adults ages 65 or older also more likely to have had a routine physical and more likely to have received a flu vaccine than their younger peers. And people who were uninsured, which I just kind of alluded to, were the least likely to have had a routine physical with 44% having one in the last year and the least likely to have a flu vaccine, 17.8% having had one in the last year.
So let's move on to the predictive probabilities. In table three, you can see here we're looking specifically at that routine physical. So we adjusted, we controlled for age and we looked at the intersections of rurality, disability status and health insurance. Among people who were privately insured, rural residents with disabilities had a probability of having a routine physical compared to rural residents without a disability, had a higher probability. I'm sorry, I misread that note there. Higher probability of having a routine physical compared to rural residents without a disability. And examining across insurance type and within rurality and disability status, people who were uninsured in all four rurality and disability groups had lower probabilities of having a routine physical compared to their privately insured counterparts. That had a wide range there as far as the actual specific metrics, but that was the basic story in terms of uninsurance across rurality and disability status.
Yeah, I think let's go ahead and move on to table four. Table three and table four, we have a lot of mixed results, so it's hard to explain in a very short period of time. After I present some results from table four, I'll go through some broader discussion and implications of these two just so we don't get hung up on the very specific measures. And again, all of this is available on our website and through the Rural Health Research Gateway on these publicly available PDF policy briefs. So table four finally shows the predicted probabilities of our second measure of interest, that's receiving the flu vaccines. We just looked at physical, now we're looking at flu vaccine. Again, controlling for age, but we're looking here at intersections of rurality, disability status, and health insurance. We find a few significant differences here between rurality and disability groups within insurance types.
So among privately insureds, we're looking just at private insurance, rural residents without disabilities had the lowest probability of being vaccinated for the flu. And among those with Medicaid, urban residents with disabilities had an almost 15 percentage point higher probability of flu vaccine compared to their rural counterparts without disabilities. That's the biggest gap there. Examining across health insurance type within rurality and disability status, people who were uninsured within three of the four rurality and disability groups had lower probabilities of that flu vaccine compared to their privately insured counterparts. Again, insurance really matters here and rural people with disabilities on Medicaid had a 16 percentage point lower probability of receiving a flu vaccine compared to their counterparts with private insurance.
So overall in this brief, kind of a complicated story and a little bit difficult to tease out in a short period of time, but we find that lack of health insurance remains a real barrier to having a flu vaccine or a routine physical in the past year with uninsured folks much likely to have received these preventive services regardless of the rurality, whether they're an urban or rural location or their disability status, whether or not they have a disability, that an uninsured status remains a real problem to accessing quality of care.
And while preventive services tend to be covered by insurance, the out-of-pocket cost on those services without insurance may make it less likely for the uninsured to seek out those preventive services. The results are a bit complicated between... There's not one clear story. It really differs by specific type of insurance and disability or location. I guess the key takeaway I would say to wrap up this slide before I kick it over to my colleague Katie Rydberg to talk about case studies and some promising models would just be to say that we showed significant differences in the quality of care as measured by those two preventative services. We found that people with disabilities and those with insurance are generally more likely to have had a routine physical and a flu vaccine regardless of rurality.
And I just would say that quality of care is really essential to promoting overall population health. And to the extent that quality of care varies by rurality, by disability status and by insurance status, especially at the intersection of all three of these, more policy attention is critically needed to ensuring that people have access to the services that they need. Now I will kick it over to Katie Rydberg to talk about some promising models as we end our time here today.
Katie Rydberg: Thanks, Mariana. All right. So as we already noted in this presentation, transportation is a critical need for rural residents with disabilities who, as you may recall, reported the highest rates of delaying medical care due to lack of transportation. So accessible transportation is a really critical component, not only though for access to healthcare, but for full participation in society as well as for quality of life. However, people with disabilities face distinct challenges related to accessing transportation. And then on top of that, with the intersection of people with disabilities living in rural areas, they face overlapping challenges in access to transportation and require some specialist considerations and support in order to live healthy lives. So our purpose with the case studies is we really wanted to get a sense of programs in rural areas that are meeting this critical need for their population with disabilities. And so to do this, we conducted a series of case studies focused on highlighting rural organizations with programs focused on providing transportation for rural residents with disabilities.
So we identified rural organizations with programs focused on providing transportation for people with disabilities through an environmental scan, and we interviewed staff from the United Community Action Partnership in Marshall, Minnesota and Mountain Rides in Ketchum, Idaho as part of this case study series. And each of these case study interviews asked about specifics of their programs as well as challenges and opportunities related to providing transportation for people with disabilities in their respective rural areas. All right, so here our first organization we highlighted is United Community Action Partnership, otherwise known as UCAP, and they are a grassroots nonprofit organization that offers programs spanning different community and family services such as head start, housing, tax preparation, childcare programs, community projects, youth development, and transportation, which we'll be talking about today. So they're based in Marshall, Minnesota, but UCAP serves nine counties throughout Southwest Minnesota with their accessible public transportation and volunteer driver services.
And we've got a really nice map here that shows their service area for your reference, and you can really see how spread out their service area is throughout Southwest Minnesota. Next slide. All right. We were really blown away by the work that they do to serve rural residents in this area. They have 40 accessible buses and over 50 hired drivers for their Community Transit Program alongside a volunteer driver program to provide transportation for individuals to areas outside of the service area that their transit program has. They also have two wheelchair accessible vans owned by UCAP as part of their volunteer driver program. The Community Transit Program provides around 200,000 rides a year and their volunteer driver program provides around 16,000 rides a year, which is a lot of rides. The Community Transit Program is funded through the 5311 formula grants for rural areas, which is through the Federal Transit Authority, and the Volunteer Driver Program is funded through outside contracts that they have with local counties and other partner organizations.
I want to share a couple of quotes from our interview with UCAP, and the first here is from Nick Leske, the director of transportation at UCAP, and he said the drivers put a lot of effort into making sure that those folks are safe and secure. Obviously, they can't just plop down and put on a seatbelt like everyone else there in their device and they need to be able to travel safely. I think that is something that we take pride in knowing that we can get them there. We also heard from and spoke with Shelly Pflaum, their mobility administrator, and she also mentioned that each of these trips is a person. Each of these trips for these people is allowing them to stay here. It is allowing them to live so they can stay where they are, which is probably where they want to be.
I think these quotes really encompass what it takes to provide the services that they do and the way the program leaders and staff see their work as more than just a ride, but they're supporting an entire life and the ability for a rural resident with disabilities to be able to live in their rural community.
Like I mentioned earlier, we also highlighted Mountain Rides, which is a public transportation system that offers services throughout the Wood River Valley of Idaho, and that includes the cities of Bellevue, Hailey, Ketchum, and Sun Valley, and their route spans 17 miles through the valley. Mountain Rides receives funding also through the 5311 formula grants for rural areas through the Federal Transit Administration. Mountain Rides has two programs for people with disabilities through American Disabilities Act, the ADA services, as well as a community health transport program. They have six vehicles for ADA service, which provide curb-to-curb services for residents with disabilities, including medical appointments as well as for other errands such as going grocery shopping or going to the post office. The Community Transit Program provides transportation from Bellevue to Twin Falls, which is about 65 miles away. And this program is specifically intended for medical appointments in Twin Falls, which has a larger hospital and dialysis service in the area.
And so Mountain Rides has a good relationship with many medical providers, including the larger hospital in Twin Falls, where social workers have helped notify patients about this service, which I think is really great. And so the entire Mountain Rides transportation system is fare-free, which is an extremely valuable asset to the communities that they serve for all rural residents, including those with disabilities. And so as we wrap up here, I do want to share this quote by Jamie Canfield, the director of transit operations, and they said, "I'm not going to deny someone service who is in a wheelchair or who can't get out of their driveway or get into their car or whatever, and you know they don't have a way to get to the hospital." I couldn't honestly feel good about that, but I mean, this is a service where we're trying to help people.
And so again, I think this really reiterates the importance of providing these transportation services for people, rural residents with disabilities. And so I'll pass things back to Carrie to wrap things up.
Carrie Henning-Smith: Thank you, Katie. Okay, we just took you on a whirlwind tour that in many ways was a mile wide and an inch deep, but I'm hoping that everyone took something useful from this, and also that this is spurring additional questions and ideas and avenues for future research and policy work. To sum it all up, what we just covered, rurality and disability are closely intertwined and there are barriers to access and outcomes at that intersection that need to be addressed. Access barriers are more pronounced by disability status than rurality that comes from the findings that Mariana showed. We focus so often on rural access to care, which is good and appropriate, but what we find is that those access barriers are really concentrated among individuals with disability in rural places.
We also found that county level dynamics matter, as does insurance coverage. The experience of access to care is not uniform across degrees of rurality, across states, across location, certainly not uniform across disability type and disability experience, and not uniform across insurance coverage or access to financial resources. Finally, Katie showed a couple of case studies that offer promising models of innovation to address the unique challenges of accessing care in rural places for people with disability. There are so many other models here that deserve attention. We only had time for a couple today, but certainly a lot of innovation happening in this space across the country.
At this point, we will take questions. You can type questions into the chat, and I appreciate the questions that people have been typing in, and I see Katie and Mariana have popped back in to help answer those questions, and I want to leave this slide for Gateway. Per, do you want to offer any final words?
Per Ostmo: Yep. Just a reminder, the slide deck transcript and recording will be made available on the Gateway website in just a couple of days. As we jump into our QA here, all of you in the audience, you are such valuable stakeholders in the rural health field, so please use the Q&A function to submit your questions, your comments, your concerns, because your input can help guide future research. So I'm going to let the researchers now review the Q&A and answer some questions.
Carrie Henning-Smith: Thank you, Per. I appreciate the questions that have been coming in. I've been trying to keep an eye on them. Looks like we have some great questions. We probably won't have time for all of them today, but we will do our best. I'm just going to start at the top here, and we had a question from Doris about whether we were going to be covering early childhood and youth disability data. Unfortunately, that was not a large focus of this project, but certainly one that deserves and requires attention. There's only so much that we can do and do well within a 12-month project period, but that is an issue area that is on our radar and that we know requires additional attention. And then Doris also lifts up the importance of community health workers, doulas, and others, and whether those were included in the provider data. There is some provider data on them, but tracking provider data on community health workers on doulas is complicated, and again, was not a focus of this project, but is something that certainly requires more attention.
I'm going to move on to Teresa's question here, rightly mentioning criticism of the ACS disability measure. There are so many caveats for all of the disability measures that we mentioned in this study. We know that there are enormous limitations on what any national survey can capture with disability. We tried to address that in part using multiple measures and multiple surveys. Certainly, there's nuance that we're not capturing in this project and that requires additional attention, and I just appreciate the lifting up of that. The measurement of disability and the measurement of rurality for that matter are topics that deserve their own webinars and that require a lot of digging into.
Mariana and Katie, feel free to hop in here too.
Mariana Tuttle: Oh, I was going to say for the question, Doris's second question about data sets for consumers of Medicare under 65 as it relates to a project that we are doing this year. So it's a very good question, and please stay tuned. This is a space we're just digging into right now.
Carrie Henning-Smith: Yes, Doris, I'm so glad you asked that. So the question here, in case people haven't seen it, are there data sets for consumers of Medicare under 65? And yes, there are. And as Mariana mentioned, we are doing a study right now looking at exactly that. We're trying to better understand rural urban differences in health outcomes and access to care for Medicare beneficiaries under 65, and we know that that is intricately intertwined with disability status. For that research, we're using the National Health Interview Survey again, so you'll see that one again, but we are also using the Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey, which surveys Medicare beneficiaries specifically and asks them a variety of questions about their use of and access to care. We'll also be doing some qualitative work, some key informant interviews on that project.
Let's see. We had a question here about the case studies, and Katie, I'm wondering if you could speak to this. The question is whether the case studies were across disability type, including neurodivergence, or whether they were focused on a specific type of disability or a subset, being those with HCBS waiver. There's a lot to unpack in this question.
Katie Rydberg: Yeah, absolutely. And we kept this very broad just because there are so many different types of disabilities, and so we just wanted to keep it as inclusive as possible. And so this was really general for services and programs that serve people with disabilities generally. But it was, I recall specifically in my conversation with UCAP that they did mention that they could possibly be serving even more people with disabilities than they know of just because there are so many different types, and particularly with neurodivergence, that people just might not be aware of. And so we just specifically kept it really broad. However, I think it would be really interesting and would be a great project in the future to dive deeper into programs maybe serving different disability types, as well as you mentioned also the HCBS waiver. There's lots of opportunities there for future work.
Carrie Henning-Smith: Thanks, Katie. We had a question from Mitchell about home delivery, telemedicine, care coordination. Those were not... I feel like a broken record now, but those were not big focus areas of this particular project, this project that was really trying to get that first step of understanding access. But I think that all of those issues are important next steps in understanding the nuance and where there's potential innovation. I will say we've made it now 58 minutes into our hour together and haven't mentioned the Rural Health Transformation Program. This is the $50 billion infusion into rural health across all 50 states. And I know there are lots of thoughts and feelings about this program, but the program in a lot of states is focused on issues of care coordination and telemedicine, in some cases, remote home monitoring, home delivery. And we are keeping an eye on that to better understand how that's incorporating disability and how those funds are being used for disability.
So I would say I would point Mitchell and others toward that to try and understand where there might be innovations happening and where there's opportunity for additional innovation. I think we have time for maybe just one or two more, but I see a question from Julie about info and other promising models on our website. We do, and we often do case studies as parts of our project, so I would encourage you to look at our website for the case studies, but I'm going to put in a huge plug here for our friends at the Rural Health Information Hub, RHI Hub. This is a federally-funded website and close colleagues of ours at the Rural Health Research Gateway and the Rural Health Research Centers. They are an incredible resource on all things rural health, and they do have a lot of promising models on serving individuals with disability and on improving access to care in rural places, so I appreciate the opportunity to plug them. If you don't have that website bookmarked, you should. It's incredible.
And I think that that takes us to the end of our hour, so I don't want to go over, but if people have additional questions, you can certainly reach out to us. We are always happy to hear from people.
Per Ostmo: Yeah. Thank you everyone for being here. We do have a copy of all the Q&A questions and our researchers will get that copy after this webinar is over. So they'll be able to follow up with any questions that we didn't answer. I appreciate everyone for being here. Thank you to our researchers for the time and their work, and I hope to see everyone at future Gateway webinars. Take care, everyone.
Carrie Henning-Smith: Thank you.